SEARCH MUSLIMAH2MUSLIMAH

There was an error in this gadget

Thursday, November 5, 2009

The Kaabah: The One Place on Earth Not Destroyed in '2012'

What even Roland Emmerich won't destroy: an Islamic landmark

In Roland Emmerich's upcoming global demolition derby movie 2012, the director gets to indulge his passion for destroying landmarks on a world scale.

In previous movies, he's destroyed the Empire State Building and the White House (Independence Day), sent a giant monster into the middle of Manhattan (Godzilla), blown away the famous Hollywood sign and the Capitol Records building in Los Angeles (The Day After Tomorrow) and savaged New York again by flooding and then freezing it (also The Day After Tomorrow).

In 2012, he takes on landmarks in Rome, Rio de Janeiro and, yes, Washington, but there is one place even he couldn't bring himself to obliterate. We caught up with Emmerich in Jackson Hole, Wyo., where he told us why he chose various landmarks to lay waste in 2012, and about the one that got away.


"I always like I think when it feels very new and original," Emmerich said, adding: "Landmarks are always symbols, just symbols. ... They stand for something."



Obviously.

This time around, he has a giant wave striking it. A wave carrying the aircraft carrier John F. Kennedy.

"I think my favorite in this one is like the White House destruction," he said. "I didn't want to go there again, and [co-writer/producer] Harald [Kloser] pretty much convinced me that I have to. And then I was brooding for days and days and days, and then I kind of had the idea: ... I've got JFK kind of coming back to the White House, which I thought was ironic."

The Poseidon



Well, not really. It's a cruise ship that rolls over much like the ill-fated ship from The Poseidon Adventure and its recent remake.

"The most striking image for me of any disaster movie was when the ship in Poseidon Adventure rolls over," Emmerich says. "I pay homage to that. ... For me it's always the most striking image of all the disaster movies. Because it's a really big object that rolls over."

The Sistine Chapel in the Vatican



That includes the famous frescoed ceiling by Michelangelo depicting Adam touching fingers with God.

"I always try to come up with what makes sense for the story, you know?" Emmerich says. "And it's not only about the destruction. It has to kind of stand for something. One of my favorite pieces of art is Michelangelo's Sistine Chapel: ... God ... reaches out to Adam, and the crack goes through it. It's just an interesting kind of notion."

St. Peter's Basilica in the Vatican



"Why ... don't [we] have the church fall on people's head?" Emmerich said. He added: "The whole Vatican kind of tips and kind of rolls over the people. It said something, because in the story, some people ... believe in praying and prayer, and they pray in front of the church, and it's probably the wrong thing, what they would do in that situation."

Christ the Redeemer statue in Rio de Janeiro






"Because I'm against organized religion," Emmerich says.

... and the one that got away...


Emmerich said that he got approached by people who wanted their landmarks destroyed, such as the 101 Tower in Taipei, the world's tallest building (pictured below).

But Emmerich was thinking of something even more explosive: the Kaaba, the cube-shaped building at the heart of Mecca, the focus of prayers and the Islamic pilgrimage called the Hajj; it is one of Islam's holiest sites.

Really?

"Well, I wanted to do that, I have to admit," Emmerich says. "But my co-writer Harald said I will not have a fatwa on my head because of a movie. And he was right. ... We have to all ... in the Western world ... think about this. You can actually ... let ... Christian symbols fall apart, but if you would do this with [an] Arab symbol, you would have ... a fatwa, and that sounds a little bit like what the state of this world is. So it's just something which I kind of didn't [think] was [an] important element, anyway, in the film, so I kind of left it out."


-Article taken from www.scifiwire.com
Written by: Patrick Lee


So, what do you think the producer's REAL reason is for not destroying the Kaabah in his movie? Is he afraid of a "fatwa"? Did he really think that the Kaabah wasn't important? Does he have some other unkown reason??? What do you think about this article overall?

6 comments:

  1. Allahu alim, but i do feel if he made that, not only would a fatwa be on his head, but im sure he seen how the muslim reacted to that drawing of the prophet and aishah and i wouldnt want that either! not to mention we make up alot of the population that goes to see these movies. but who knows he may actually believe its just plain disrespectful... i know alot of people who dont believe in organized religion but if they did they'd be muslim, and they respect islam the most

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello,

    I think similarly with the person above. If he does something like that to a Christian symbol, he knows he can get away with it but he can't do the same for an Islamic symbol because muslims around the world will react very strongly to that. That says something really good about our religion and its followers, doesn't it? We're united, we have the utmost respect for our religion and things that are related to it, above all. It also suggests that Islam has more devoted followers than Christian does, although Christian is the religion with the most followers (by name only, perhaps).

    ReplyDelete
  3. as long he doesn't show the destruction of Kaabah, it's ok. it a good movie though, it makes people feared of death.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Interesting! Seriously, I have no idea. But, I don't think it's just because he fears death threats... And yes, Christians don't care, so let their symbols fall, they will not react, but if you do it with Muslims - they would probably want to kill you... But at least, we care! I think that there is something in it... The Sistine Chapel fresque must be ruined because it contains an antropomorphisation and imagination of God and the statue must be ruined because it is made for idolatry. Christian symbols falling teach the world that Christianity has gone astray and will fail at the end, but that Kaaba resists - is a sign to us all, that Islam is the only true, victorious religion on the Day of Judgement... Allaahu 'alam.

    ReplyDelete
  5. well, case can be seen in many different ways, how about this: Christian thinks that God no need to be protected, instead God will protect his follower and the religion. In the contrary, Muslims thinks that Allah need to be protected for any cost, even life. I Thought as muslims we should be pissed off if any of us brings to much hatred to the people that mock us/our religion. Islam should be peaceful and let Allah himself do whatever necessary to those who hate us. Why don't we just pray for them?

    ReplyDelete

Be sure to leave us a comment! We enjoy negative, but we LOOOOVE the positive!!!